ias100.in Official Website for Civil Services Chronicle IAS 100 IAS 100
GS Mains Test series 2017Prelims GS Online Course 2017
You are here: Daily Dose
The Wrong in Idea Of Universal Basic Income

The Economic Survey 2016-17  has mooted the idea of introducing a universal basic income in India. There is one whole chapter devoted to the proposal. The idea encompasses an universal and unconditional income transfer to all citizens. This is seen as a way to address the twin problems of poverty and unemployment. The basic feature of universal basic income is that the state provides to all citizens without a means test and without a work requirement.


It is unconditional  and not tied to work or employment and it is universal and not targeted. 
The Economic Survey, however, gets it all wrong – in terms of purpose of the proposal, alternative welfare measures with the government and the redistributive intent.

In his book, Real Freedom for All, Philippe Van Parijs, the left-liberal political philosopher argues that  the basis for universal basic income is the “fair distribution of real freedom to pursue the realization of one’s conception of the good life”.

Existing guaranteed incomes schemes are often linked to employment status and have a threshold level of income, that is, they are means-tested.  A negative income tax is the alternative to universal basic income. 

There are several distortions in Indian proposal in Economic Survey. It wants universal basic income to replace the existing social welfare and anti-poverty programmes,  not supplement it. A crusade for a greater income security should  not neglect the importance  of  quality  basic health care  and basic education. The Economic Survey’s statement that “universal basic income is not framed as a transfer payment from the rich to the poor.” is another wrong. The resources required would have to come through progressive taxation or consumption tax. Unless the government  decides to  increase tax resources, a universal basic income is just a diversion from social and economic problems in the country.

Share Button

Subscribe IAS100 Newsletter

  UPSC Daily Dose : Current Affairs
Governments aadhar link to social welfare
Poor votes or demon EVM
The need for a different time zone for north east
Health care and Indias new policy
Deriving water from waste water
How to go right about Indian health expediture
A new world, a bolder foreign policy
The future that u.p. election results behold
Figment of polluted minds
Campuses in India and raging debates
Is raddul fasaad going to end up like zarb-e-azb
The Wrong in Idea Of Universal Basic Income
Indias bits and protection of rights of tribals
The quandary of diverging india
The pakistan establishment, terror groups and geopolitics
Name* :   
  E-mail* :   
  Mobile* :   

  Your Query* :

Home | About Us | Contact Us | Terms & Conditions | Refund Policy | Delivery Policy | Disclaimer | Copyright Policy | Privacy policy |
Partner sites :chronicleias.com | chronicleindia.in | cgmantra.in
GS Mains Test series 2017 View Details Prelims GS Online Course 2017View Details Prelims CSAT Online Course 2017View Details


Please Give Your Valuable FEEDBACK To Serve You Better.

Please enter security code, displayed below !
(Note: code should be entered in small letters)